Harrogate Spring Water expansion rejected

Plans to expand the Harrogate Spring Water site in Harrogate have been dramatically rejected by North Yorkshire Council, following intense public opposition and a high-profile campaign to protect Rotary Wood.

The proposed development, backed by Danone, promised more than 50 new jobs and a £2.3 million annual boost to the local economy. But it came at the cost of around 500 trees in a woodland many residents consider part of Harrogate’s identity.

Councillors refused the application despite planning officers recommending approval, raising concerns that replacement planting would not make up for the loss and that the design failed to fit the local environment.

The decision follows more than 1,000 objections, a peaceful protest outside the planning meeting, and vocal opposition from well-known figures including Judi Dench, Joanna Lumley, Sam West and Jonathan Porritt.

Dame Judi Dench described Rotary Wood as a “living woodland” built by the community, warning it should not be treated as expendable.

Harrogate and Knaresborough MP Tom Gordon welcomed the outcome, saying “common sense has prevailed,” but cautioned that future proposals could still threaten the site.

Harrogate Spring Water said it was “disappointed” by the decision, insisting the plans balanced environmental responsibility with economic growth. The company is now reviewing its options, including a possible appeal or revised application.

The ruling marks a major moment in one of Harrogate’s most contentious planning battles, with the future of Rotary Wood still uncertain.